The ‘Screw-It’ Job Market: Why Applicants Are Getting Weird to Beat AI
As AI-generated résumés flood corporate inboxes, job seekers are turning to unconventional tactics—from Taylor Swift lyrics to 'mermaiding'—to prove they are human.
The Rise of the ‘Human’ Pitch
In a job market increasingly saturated with automated, AI-polished applications, candidates are adopting a “screw-it” mentality to stand out. With recruiters facing an average of 194 applications per hire, many are struggling with “résumé fatigue,” finding that most submissions sound identical. To combat this, job seekers are moving beyond traditional professional summaries, opting for bold, sometimes eccentric, tactics to signal their humanity.
Amanda McDormand, a 43-year-old senior leader, found herself in this position after being laid off. Faced with a flood of auto-rejections, she began experimenting with her cover letters. Her breakthrough came when she incorporated Taylor Swift lyrics into a pitch, framing her professional experience through the lens of pop culture. The strategy worked, securing her a fractional role and eventually a full-time position. For McDormand, the goal was to provide something memorable in a sea of monotony.
Why Conventional Résumés Are Failing
Recent data from Ladders suggests that over 84% of job seekers now use AI to draft or edit their résumés. This widespread reliance on technology has prompted 76% of surveyed candidates to take deliberate steps to sound less like a machine. Recruiters, such as Kristin Raiford, note that after reviewing hundreds of similar-sounding documents, they become hyper-selective, searching for any detail that distinguishes one candidate from the next.
The trend has led to a resurgence of “interest” sections on résumés featuring unusual details. Recruiters report seeing everything from “clowning” and “mermaiding” to “lucid dreaming” and “buffalo chicken wraps.” Some applicants are even intentionally including minor punctuation or spelling errors to prove a human hand was at work, while others use informal language, such as referring to themselves as an “in-house girly,” to break the sterile tone of AI-generated text.
The Strategy Behind the Eccentricity
For some, these unconventional details serve a dual purpose: grabbing a recruiter’s attention and providing an easy bridge into interview conversations. Kelsey Anderson, a graduate student, lists “Julia Child” as an interest, which allows her to pivot from cooking to deeper discussions about American food dynamics or career pivots. Similarly, marketing professional Paige Maly included a visual scale of her “wildest adventures” on her résumé. She argues that this was not just a stunt, but a way to demonstrate traits like independence and risk-taking.
A High-Stakes Gamble
While these tactics can be effective, experts warn that they are not a universal solution. Erica Keswin, a workplace strategy author and former executive recruiter, notes that while creative industries might embrace a quirky application, traditional sectors like law or consulting may view them as unprofessional. The risk of these tactics “backfiring” is significant if the personality trait feels forced or inauthentic.
Ultimately, the consensus among recruiters and successful candidates is that while a creative cover letter or an odd hobby might get a foot in the door, it is only the beginning. As McDormand noted, these techniques are a way to initiate contact, but once the interview begins, the candidate must possess the substance to back up their claims. In an era where AI can mimic professional language, the ability to connect personal interests to meaningful strategy remains a uniquely human advantage.
Source: businessinsider.com
Enjoyed this story?
Get more important stories from ViralBrief delivered directly to your inbox.

Join the conversation
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thoughtful response.